Centre for Law and Social Justice
Julius Malema and the Roots of Fascism in South Africa
I met a young man called Lubabalo Folose because I regularly pass through his place of work – O.R. Tambo International Airport near Johannesburg. Neatly dressed and always smiling, he shines shoes. A few years ago he persuaded me to let him shine my shoes “because if you are in the Treatment Action Campaign you must have clean shoes” he said.
Lubabalo’s shoe shining techniques are good but his analysis and questioning of contemporary politics is always more astute than many commentators. We have become friends because I have learnt more about sacrifice and hard work from this man who reminds me of my parents and grand-parents than from all our political representatives.
Most days, Lubalo wakes at 03:00 and makes his way to the airport where he shines the shoes of lawyers who can earn R30 000.00 a day and business men (black and white) who make much more all use his services. At the end of the month (after working 240 hours excluding 100 hours travelling to work) Lubabalo takes home about R1000,00.
He completed matric and wanted to become a nurse or teacher but he does not have enough money to improve his grades or to study through UNISA. He lives in a shack and he refuses to marry or father children until he has saved money. Lubabalo Folose works hard and earns about R4.00 an hour. Can he be regarded as fortunate because the majority of his peers will never have an income?
The average male farm worker in Vanwyksdorp where my friend and comrade Jack Lewis has a small-holding earns R300.00 per week and he has to decide whether to feed himself or his family. Women farmworkers earn even less.
Similarly, clothing and textile workers earn starvation wages while many casual workers in the service sector hardly earn R2000.00 per month.
Class and race inequality, the conditions of immiseration, unimaginable hardship combined with a riot in luxury are at the roots of an emerging fascism in South Africa.
Julius Malema is a cunning, dangerous and popular decoy for people in the state and powerful ANC leaders linked to business. They aim to cement their power, weaken democracy and extract every ounce of fat from the state. They use the anger of the unemployed, alloy it with sexism, patriarchy and envy to create a movement.
Two obstacles bar the way of Malema, corrupt civil servants and business leaders to the bank: the over-privileged and very often racist white minority and the vast mass of poor and working people.
White people are an easy target but not the central obstacle.
The Democratic Alliance and their business allies have similar objectives to Malema: ensure greater profits for business and protect privileged lifestyles. The mines, farms, the hotels, the casinos, retail outlets and tenders owned or eyed by Malema and his backers can only make excessive profits if they drive down wages and conditions of workers.
The divisive racism against white people must be combated but it is also a smoke-screen for an even more dangerous agenda. For enfeebled, entitled and greedy black business (and their powerful white counter-parts) to profiteer, the solidarity and organisation of working class people must be destroyed.
Both white and black business and their representatives want to use the poorest, most vulnerable and marginalised people against the working class. How often do we hear the refrain from economists such as Nicoli Nattrass at UCT to political leaders such as Tony Leon and Helen Zille that the labour laws and the trade union “aristocracy” prevent business growth?
These paragons of constitutional virtue would not object to a constitutional amendment that removes fair labour practices Representatives of privileged and upper-class interests have no roots among the socially disenfranchised and this is what makes Malema dangerous.
The arrogance of over-privileged white people also relies on the insecurity of white, coloured and Indian middle-classes to build a political power base. The AWB is an expression of the broad climate of racist invective from faceless white people on the internet, talk shows and private conversation that developed even before Malema.
The big black business faction of the ANC cannot inscribe “Enrich yourself” on its banner instead it has to wear the garments of Robert Mugabe. Nationalisation and land occupations represent their route to power. The business people in the ANC who regard themselves as progressive have to openly condemn Malema.
The presence of the trade unions in the African National Congress together with an independent progressive civil society and socially engaged religious communities represents the real alternative and the possibility and probability of a more equal and just distribution of income and wealth. They are also the real target of Malema and his business faction.
Right now, Cosatu must take the initiative to call together leaders and organisations of civil society, religious bodies and all labour federations to condemn the emerging fascism that uses the ANC for black business. Julius Malema must be condemned by every trade union leader.
Cosatu must build and lead a political campaign for fair global labour and trade standards, equal education, health for all, and sustained public investment. In addition, it must demand just and fair economic union in Southern Africa because our growth path will be strengthened with the development of Angola, DRC and the smaller countries in our region.
The ANC leadership has allowed this situation to develop. Only after they faced international media condemnation because of Malema (and his cruel antics that insults people of Zimbabwe) the leadership developed some backbone. As an ANC member, I ask that Julius Malema and his clique be removed from our movement.
Zackie Achmat
09 April 2010
| Print article | This entry was posted by Zackie Achmat on 09/04/2010 at 18:44, and is filed under Uncategorized. Follow any responses to this post through RSS 2.0. You can leave a response or trackback from your own site. |



about 4 months ago
Well spoken! We must focus on building a nation built on respect,equality and reconciliation!
about 4 months ago
Hi Zackie,
Thank you for this! I really hope that this article is widely read.
Just one question… How many people within the ANC feel this way?
about 4 months ago
I’m with you on this, and also believe that COSATU is the only group that seems to have shown any shred of sense in the past few years
about 4 months ago
Very true brother. It is rather unfortunate that we as citizens allow greed and unethical business practices polarise our nation. We need to take stock of our environment. Thank you for the thought provoking article.
about 4 months ago
Yes, please. I was bitterly disappointed when the Communist Party was not on the ballot in the last election. COSATU must challenge the ANC head-on, but with even Mrs Vavi proving to be venal, I do feel both weary and wary. Perhaps it’s time to start a new coalition for fair labour practice? A grass roots rights lobby group, much like the TAC?
about 4 months ago
Cosatu is just posturing because they didn’t get their cut of the money on 3 very specific deals.
If they had been allowed to have a more active role in government as they requestsed, they would never have said a word.
They are just a jilted lover in a corrupt game, nothing more.
about 4 months ago
Craig
You are wrong. Cosatu has seriously resisted ANC antics on HIV, Zimbabwe, corruption, self-enrighment, economic policy. For this there is ample evidence.
Cosatu’s strategy and tactics need modernising but that is a different debate. Faceless smears and innuendo are not debates.
Zackie
about 4 months ago
From your lips to God’s ears, Zachie, but will it happen (removal of ANCYL faction)? I’m really not sure… & what of the powers that be that allowed all this to happen, for their own ends mind you, what will become of them & their aspirations?
about 4 months ago
Zuma is a captive of those who brought him to power – most prominantely Malema. He needs to be either freed from the bondage of the opportunistic and corrupt foces that hold him captive or replaced. There needs to be multiple voices speaking out against the present trend in the ANC and openly advocating for a new way. There are good people in Zumas’s cabinet – Patel, Davies, Hogan, Motsoaledi, Joemat-Pietersen, Deputy President Motlante with his roots in the Union movement and perhaps Pravim Gordan and, although not includeable in the list of “good people” because their bs levels are just to high, Nzimande and Cronin and maybe a couple of others. If they took a stand in favour of non-racialism, open accountable government, freedom of speech and for the constitution and against corruption and cronyism and with a commitment to forming a new social contract for SA – a new “negotiated settelment” – to find a third way between monopoly capital dominance of the ecnomy and the inefficiency of state ownership – through something like an RDP fund – if this were to happen, then Vavi, Cosatu and the other union federations would join such a grouping and a movement would be created within the ANC and outside of it and in society to harness the huge will which exists in the working class and across classes in South Africa to build a functional modern soceity and not to allow the vast majorty of the country to be held capitve by thugish bullies like Malema, Visagie and other backward forces. Now really is a moment when good people need to speak out to create a counter wave to the negative tendency the forces of backwardness are promoting.
about 4 months ago
Thank you Zackie. There is nothing remotely revolutionary about Julius Malema. His rhetoric is tired and backward, his behaviour a shameful example to the youth he claims to represent, his politics shallow and devisive and his tactics neo-fascist. As a former cadre in MK I join you in a call to leadership to take responsibility for Malema’s behaviour and remove him from his pulpit before he can do further damage. His pinhole world view is not what we fought for! Aluta continua. Amandla!
about 4 months ago
Thank you, an inciteful analysis.
Malema is not a representative of anything but his own greed.
The inbalance between wealth and poverty widens all around the world. I suspect we won’t be alone in dealing with it in future.
We do have a wonderful constitution. If we could ensure real widespread ownership of companies, and get rid of the cronyism and corruption that is depriving the citizens of the benefits that should accrue from what is being spent, we’d have a better country.
I have wondered for while, just when do the ANC feel someone is no longer a youth and should join the mainstream party and leave the youth organisation to the young.
about 4 months ago
The first half of your article appears pointless and disjointed from the (much better) second half. You appear to see only black and white and then you attack some white businessman strawman that you appear to have formed because you are a jetsetter yourself. I guess if you fly around all the time you can get a warped sense of reality. I don’t think I ever meet white people that make 30k and more per day. And why single out white people? What happened to all the shades of the rainbow?
Then you use a Malema rant as an opportunity to smear the opposition? Like they would definitely vote for changing the constitution to get rid of laws protecting the poor? Wtf?
I’m very weary of Cosatu. They are a labour union. They only care about themselves and their own existing members, not about the unemployed poor or non-cosatu members. The only chance that they might care about the poor and job creation is if it could directly result in swelling their own ranks and therefore increasing their own power.
Looking out for union members’ immediate interests is not necessarily the best way to go about fixing, improving or advancing the country or the southern african region.
But yes. Perhaps they are the lesser evil when it comes to the tri-partite alliance. And EVERYONE should grow a spine and act to get rid of Malema. At this point you shouldn’t have to spend too much effort convincing people. You certainly don’t have to lump ordinary people in with the AWB. In the last few days there appears to be this new paranoia where people greatly overestimate their numbers. That’s the worst thing that came out of all of this – suddenly every second white person is viewed as an AWB supporter.
about 4 months ago
Thanks Zackie. There is a fear about attacking Malema amongst good people, and you have the ability to break that open by setting an example — I hope that happens.
I want to raise one issue for further discussion: Malema is a danger because there are 2.4 million unemployed 18-25 year olds in South Africa. Half of those are young men, and many of those do, or could, feel that Malema speaks for them. What is the way to deal with this? You advocate for global labour standards — if that kind of movement was successful it would drive up the cost of labour in China and elsewhere and improve the chances for employment of South African youth. But what in the meanwhile, which is likely to be a few decades? Do you rule out more flexible employment rules for youth? Equal Education is obviously directed at exactly the problem I am raising. But there need to be other initiatives in terms of the labour market, training etc. If this was done reasonably successfully the Malemas would become a more manageable problem.
about 4 months ago
Zackie, South African labour is hopelessly inefficient and underskilled as it stands and its unions are protecting its own interests against that of the unemployed. It is fair to say that South Africans generally have an overdeveloped sense entitlement and suffer from underdeveloped aspirations, compared to say, South Korean workers. And we do not have a national culture that sees education as a priority – we spent enormous amounts on education each year, yet we are falling off the already abominable standards set under apartheid. We have a systemic issue. I blame the politicisation of education by trade unions such as SADTU. A well-educated, productive work force can lift millions of people out of poverty. The GDP of Singapore and South Korea was about the same as that of South Afirc ain the 50′s, today it is 8-10 times larger. The big difference: educations and aspiration. True empowerment of the masses can only come through good governance and service delivery: education and hard work. Carry on believing you are exploited by capitalism, and South Africa will continue to fall back in the Human Development Index. Unsuccesful countries avoid the hard things succesful countries do. The day we stop demanding “jobs” and start demanding to “work” is the day things will turn. Inconvenient to South Africn ears, but true.
about 4 months ago
I have no comment about the politics, since it is an entirely subjective thing.
But I will say that your article is badly written, Zackie, and oddly structured. It makes your point broken and illegible and difficult to understand (not that it isn’t anyway). Still, it’s about to be considered brave to speak out against Julius Malema, so points for you.
about 4 months ago
I must admit that I am not a political animal in the slightest, and any sort of politicused jargon sends me running for hills! But… it is imperative we have a full picture of all the facts regarding Julius Malema and his followers. In the last two days, I have encountered one of his ‘disciples’ who made blatantly racist and pathetically incorrect statements attacking my campaign called ‘Malema, A Love Letter’. Zackie, sorry to abuse your article for my own agenda, but I would be grateful and honoured if you contributed! http://myza.co.za/ukukulisa/2010/04/malema-a-love-letter.html
about 4 months ago
Hendrik, Le Roux and D.M
Your styles of argument are exactly what every reflective person in South Africa must reject. Why do you comment anonymously? One cannot resist without affirming one’s identity as a human being and a name is central to dignity.
Open and accountable political debate is essential. First, what is the evidence that anyone other than organisations of working and poor people such as Cosatu actually care about inequality and injustice?
The comparisons with the so-called Asian Tigers are uninformed and ahistorical. During the Cold War, the US subsidised these economies and guaranteed them markets.
Education is the key but your analysis of the problems with our education system is also shallow. I suggest you go to the website http://www.equaleducation.org.za.
Your argument that South Africans have a sense of entitlement ignores the incredible hard work of everyone from a tomato-seller and mine-worker to women who struggle to look after families.
Entitlement exists but its primary location is among the middle-classes both Black and White.
By the way Le Roux, I do not hide the fact that I am privileged and middle-class. When I am at home I use public transport most of the time.
Zackie
about 4 months ago
Hi Zackie
I think your are on to something. I hope your letter gets read by many that are in power on all sides of the political scene . Has it been published in any of the local papers? If not I think it should. Thanks for the insight.
about 4 months ago
Zackie: Then please use words like “privileged” and “middle-class” (or better yet, upper-class) in your articles and don’t just say “white” and “black”. There are already words for these concepts, please don’t hide them away in the comments.
You seem to imply that no one cares about inequality and injustice. Can you provide evidence that no one in the opposition cares? What evidence is there to suggest that Cosatu truly cares about anyone other than themselves? Does Cosatu really care about Lubabalo Folose? Consider for a moment that he’s likely not a member.
Another thought: Consider for a moment the bulk of the middle class that earns twice, perhaps three times as much money as the typical unionised poor person. That person typically has overheads like rent, downpayments on a car (that he/she doesn’t really need) and other overheads that the poor don’t have leaving them with about the same amount (perhaps a little more) of disposable income as the poor (the unionised, employed poor, not the starving unemployed, obviously) Does that car and that flat that’s being rented that she can barely afford really increase his/her standard of living by such an extent that we have to now loathe them for being “privileged”?
As far as I can tell, most of (statistically nearly all) the middle class (of whatever hue) falls into this over-leveraged, indebted category of people that are also just struggling to make ends meet.
What do you suggest they do? How can they help their fellow South Africans out of poverty?
I guess I’m just frustrated at the level of commentary I see on the internet where it seems people greatly overestimate the amount of wealth apparently being hoarded as well as the amount of people in a position to amass all that wealth.
about 4 months ago
Le Roux i have to say that i agree with you.
Jackie, i’m very interested in the nuts and bolts of how to rescue the people earning so little. How do we do this?
about 4 months ago
Interesting post. A bit difficult to follow but the point comes across.
We have common ground:
http://blogs.news24.com/Mos_Native/Julius-is-not-racist
about 4 months ago
Good article that I can only fault for its omissions – i.e. the roll of inefficiencies & corruption within the ANC in respect of service delivery & land reform.
I also don’t see the link between big business and the DA alone, what about the ANC?
And I can take issue with the constraints placed upon business big or small by the Labour Law – and NOT in respect of minimum wage. There is much more to it.
about 4 months ago
Politics have become more complex than before…at least before it was explicit that the previous government hated the non whites and its focal point was to completely suppress its opponents.
In democratic country the politics are not different from crime it contains mobs.
I cannot dwell much on COSATU as they cannot themselves describe their missions, they’ve become too political than sticking to labour relations.
As much as I wish to add comment with regard to bussiness issues I can’t since I can hardly understand its processes. What I can add is that globally there’s still major crisis in terms of trading as a result it will affect SA (developing country).
What I truly admire about Lubabalo is the mere fact that he left his small shack to create a job for himself instead of relying too much on support grant which of course he will not qualify for since it mostly offers women with multiple children, the elders, disabled but not those who are unemployed.
What needs to be stipulated here is how these Labour Relations Organization utilise their skills in making sure that those exploited by the businesses be protected with regard to these wages?
As for Malema I cannot argue as the President done little in disciplining the laiti…
The Youth Agency former Youth Development Fund has done little in assisting the school leavers, the graduates, etc.
We need a way forward here…
about 4 months ago
I agree with you too Ntombizonke. We pay income tax and VAT as SA citizens but it feel sometimes like its disappearing in the black hole of bad management and corruption. Never mind that it is clearly not enough. But just giving more money will not solve these inequalities in income either. We need to talk about solutions now so we can start fixing it. I would like people to stop crying socialist this and capitalist that and give practical solutions. I for one don’t have a degree in politics or economics and like the most of us out there we have no time to sit in committees all day and debate. We have to work hard to make a living. Summarize it, in day to day examples so we can try and do our bit as well. In the mean time we watch news at night wondering how our economy can work with all these upheavals.
about 4 months ago
As a member of the ANC and ANCWL I second Comrade Zackie Achmat’s call for Malema and his clique to be removed from the movement.
about 4 months ago
Hi Zackie
Every movement and organization will have its “malema” somewhere in its past or future.We need to be aware and take decisive action at the first signs of trouble.The ANC must have known that they had a rouge member who would try and dismantle all the hard work done by Black,White, Coloured and Indian citizens of South Africa and yet they allowed him to continue unabated until real damage was caused
!
Lubabalou Folose has a tough life ,but i believe he has the tenacity to achieve his dreams.He certainly does not need a malema,to delay achieving that dream.But there are thousands of Lubabalou’s around and what needs to happen is that the ANC government needs to channel some of the billions spent on acquiring guns of war,into the centers to teach basic skills and administration.
I taught in the past, and will do so again this year,a basic waitron and bar course ,free, to willing students.I am not allowed to give them acknowledgement of their achievements because i am prevented from issuing a certificate as i am not seta accredited( almost an impossible laborious task) but give them a letter of recommendation.This at least allows them to be employed in the hospitality industry,with some basic skills.Imagine if big money was behind such projects !
But getting back to more serious territory.I have a nephew who lives overseas and is the international buyer of produce for his company.They also establish supply countries and set up factories to supply mainly foodstuffs.On a recent visit to South Africa i asked him why they did not get supplies from here and he showed me a list indicating the labor costs versus the production of most countries around the world.I was shocked that we rank so poorly in the cost of labor against the productivity produced.
While i champion the cause for fair wages i also champion the cause for fair labor produced. Sadly we see too often the scale is lopsided.
It is difficult to criticize the source of income,but COSATU must get the labor forces into productive mode and strikes should become unheard of in this country,as should labor disputes.
You have stuck to your beliefs and although i do not support your political party,i greatly admire your dedication.Lubabalo Folose will benifit a great deal from your talks.